Castor had just called 911, worried that her husband David Castor hadn’t come out of his bedroom all weekend and that he might have committed suicide using the shotgun under his bed.
“Friday night when we were arguing, he told me to get out,” Stacey Castor told the 911 operator. “Take my kids and get out. I could leave. And then 5 minutes later, he said if I left he would make me sorry. I would be sorry if I ever left him.” She said that after the two had an argument, her husband got upset and locked himself in the bedroom.
Watch the full story on “20/20” FRIDAY, Feb. 8 at 10 p.m. ET on ABC
Finding the bedroom door at the Castors’ Liverpool, New York, home locked, Onondaga County Sheriff’s Department Sgt. Robert Willoughby broke down the door. He walked in and found David Castor’s dead, naked body on the bed.
“[Stacey Castor] asked me if he’s okay,” Willoughby told ABC News’ “20/20.” “All I said was, ‘No, he’s not.’ The paramedics go in the room. They come back out, and at this point, she’s screaming, ‘Have him come back. He’s not dead. He’s not dead.’”
“On the nightstand, next to the bed, was a short glass half-full of a green liquid, another glass that had some remnants of some juice, an apricot brandy bottle,” lead investigator Detective Dominick Spinelli, told “20/20.” “There was a cranberry juice bottle there too.”
Underneath the bed, authorities also found a bottle of antifreeze. Spinelli said another member of the sheriff’s office also found a turkey baster lying in the garbage can in the kitchen.
“I noticed that it’s got droplets inside it,” Willoughby said of the baster. “So I pick it up and I pull the rubber ball off it and I smell it and I can smell alcohol in it. I know he’s been drinking. I know alcohol is involved. I know that antifreeze is involved.”
It initially appeared to investigators that David Castor may have committed suicide by ingesting antifreeze.
But to Spinelli, things didn’t add up.
“We started sending in the physical evidence — the antifreeze bottle, the apricot brandy bottle, the glasses — to see if there was any fingerprints or DNA evidence on those items, as well as the turkey baster,” Spinelli said.
They found Stacey Castor’s fingerprints on the glass.
“The fingerprints [were] in such a way that it was as if someone held the glass from the bottom,” Spinelli said. “Could it be explained? Sure. Stacey may have put the glass in the cupboard that way from the dishwasher. I don’t know. But Stacey may have held the glass up to his mouth.”
Antifreeze was also found in the turkey baster, and David Castor’s DNA was also on the tip of the baster.
David’s sister, Linda Horzempa, said that her brother worked on cars all the time and knew that ingesting antifreeze could cause a long and painful death.
She said he was also familiar with the chemical mixture through his work at his own business, Liverpool Heating and Air Conditioning.
“David’s ex-wife Janice right off the bat started calling me, telling me that she did not believe in any way, shape or form that David would have caused self-harm,” Spinelli recalled.
“I told him just what kind of guy he was and that there’s no way he would’ve committed suicide,” David Castor’s ex-wife Janice Poissant Farmer told “20/20.” “That is so wrong, so very wrong.”
Detectives also learned that David Castor’s will left everything to Stacey Castor and her two daughters from her first marriage, but nothing to David Castor, Jr. — his son with Janice.
“I don’t even believe my name was mentioned in it,” David Castor, Jr., told “20/20.” “My first feelings on that were my father really did not like me. I thought that he was just pissed at me, like, wanted nothing to do with me and never wanted anything to do with me again.”
“David, he had campers,” Poissant Farmer continued. “He had motorcycles, jet skis, snowmobiles, a house, a business, and I figure that Stacey just had made plans to take it all.”
As they focused their investigation on how David Castor really died — and if someone may have wanted him dead — detectives sought to interview Stacey Castor’s first husband Michael Wallace, with whom Stacey Castor had two daughters, Ashley and Bree.
It turned out that Wallace, too, was dead.
Wallace’s troubles began in December 1999. He began feeling ill around the holidays.
“He was having a hard time walking, and he was having a hard time talking,” Ashley Wallace recalled about her father in a 2009 interview with “20/20.” “And one time, he sat up, and he just vomited across the coffee table and laid back down went back to sleep like nothing ever happened.”
But in Jan. 2000, Ashley Wallace, who was 12 years old when her father died, said she came home to find him lying on the couch making what she thought were funny faces. Ashley Wallace was on the phone with her mom at the time, and she hung up and went to go pick up her sister from school.
By the time Stacey returned home, Michael Wallace, 38, appeared unresponsive. He was transported to the hospital by ambulance. Doctors later determined that he had died of a heart attack.
Detectives investigating David Castor’s death obtained Michael Wallace’s medical records and found that he had a normal heart. They decided to take a closer look at the circumstances surrounding Wallace’s death and received a court’s permission to exhume his body in Sept., 2007.
“A few days later, I was walking through the criminal investigation division when I received a phone call from [the] medical examiner, and he said, ‘Hey, we just got done with the autopsy [and] I have the results for you,’” Sgt. Michael Norton, another detective on the case, recalled to “20/20.”
“’Guess what I found? He’s loaded with crystals,’” Norton continued. “And when you are poisoned with antifreeze, crystals form in your organs. And they don’t ever go away. And that was one of the reasons why we exhumed him, was so that we could find out if those crystals were still there.”
At that point, detectives believed they had a double homicide case and that Stacey Castor likely killed both of her husbands, Spinelli said.
Detectives obtained a warrant to wiretap Stacey Castor’s phones and set up cameras outside of her home to monitor her comings and goings.
Spinelli and Valerie Brogan, yet another detective on the case, interviewed Stacey Castor a second time after the results of their investigation.
“She seemed nervous,” Brogan told “20/20.” “She was pacing, and she just was surprised that we were there.”
Spinelli asked Stacey Castor about the glasses found in the bedroom where David Castor had died.
“I said, ‘Stacey, there were two glasses sitting on the nightstand. You say that you poured him some cranberry juice at one point, right?’ She said, ‘Yes.’ I said, ‘I’m going to show you a picture of those two glasses,’” recalled Spinelli.
He continued, “I asked Stacey, ‘Do you remember which glass it was that you poured the cranberry juice in?’ and she looked at it and said, ‘Well, when I poured the anti-free– I—‘ and then she stopped and said, ‘I mean– I mean, the cranberry juice.’”
“It was, like, she realizes what she’s just said,” said Brogan.
When Spinelli confronted Stacey Castor about saying “antifree–,” she stopped the interview and said she wanted an attorney.
“She said, ‘You know, I don’t like this. You’re trying to frame me. You’re trying to pin this on me,’” said Spinelli.
Spinelli said that as he picked up his folder to put the photo of the glasses back in, Stacey Castor noticed the photo of the turkey baster in the folder.
“Stacey peered at the folder and said, ‘What– what is that?’ And I said, ‘What?’ And she said, ‘That picture, what is that picture of a turkey baster? Why is that there?’” Spinelli said. “And I said, ‘Don’t worry about it. The interview’s over.’”
Authorities also visited Ashley Wallace at her college to tell her that police believed her father had died of antifreeze poisoning. After Ashley called her mother to tell her about this visit, Wallace said Stacey suggested that they have a drink together.
“[She said], ‘We’ve had a rough week. Let’s just get drunk,’” Ashley Wallace recalled her mom saying, in a 2009 interview the younger woman gave to “20/20.” “’I was like, ‘Cool!’ You know, what kind of teenager wouldn’t think that was awesome? Your parents just gave you permission to drink. Sweet!”
The first time Ashley Wallace drank a beverage mixed by her mother, she passed out and wound up in her bedroom. The next day, Ashley Wallace drank with her mother again and then went to sleep.
When Stacey Castor’s younger daughter Bree Wallace was concerned her sister hadn’t come out of her room the following morning, she went to check on her and found her unresponsive. Stacey Castor called 911.
“I need an ambulance!” Stacey Castor told the 911 operator. “My daughter had taken some pills. It sounds like there’s something in her throat.”
“Stacey relayed to the 911 dispatcher that Ashley had consumed alcohol and quite a few doses of medications,” Spinelli said.
Bree Wallace found a piece of paper that appeared to be a suicide note in her sister’s room.
Brogan said she arrived at the house to see a stretcher coming out of the home, and her sergeant handed her the letter. “As I’m reading the note, I’m realizing that it’s a confession and a suicide note all in one.
A typewritten note, more than 750 words long, was an apparent confession to the murders of Michael Wallace and David Castor with Ashley Wallace’s typed signature at the end.
“Now everyone is going to know what really happened, and they know it wasn’t you, it was me,” the note read. “Please don’t hate me. Remember, I love you.”